Google's Find My Device Network Struggles in Real-World Test
Google recently launched its Find My Device network to compete with Apple's Find My network, aiming to help users locate lost items using compatible Bluetooth trackers. However, a real-world test conducted by a tech journalist has revealed significant shortcomings in the network's performance.
The Experiment
The journalist set up multiple Bluetooth trackers from Chipolo and Pebblebee, which are compatible with Google's new network. These trackers were then distributed to friends and marked as lost in the Find My Device app. The goal was to see how effectively the network could locate these lost items in a real-world scenario.
Disappointing Results
Despite high expectations, the results were underwhelming:
- The network failed to locate any of the trackers for three days
- Trackers were only detected when in close proximity to the tester's phone
- The Find My Device map often failed to load or show the location of found devices
- Notifications about found devices were delayed or inconsistent
Key Issues Identified
- Limited Network Participation: Many Android users haven't opted into contributing to the network, severely limiting its effectiveness.
- Privacy Settings Confusion: Google offers multiple options for network participation, which may be confusing for users.
- Notification Problems: Alerts about unknown trackers could potentially scare off people who might otherwise help return lost items.
- Map Functionality: The inability to see found devices on the map reduces the network's usefulness.
Google's Response
Google has acknowledged these issues and stated they are actively working to roll out enhancements in the coming weeks. They expect improvements in speed and accuracy as more devices join the network.
Looking Ahead
While the initial test results are disappointing, there's still hope for Google's Find My Device network. As more users opt in and Google addresses the current shortcomings, the service could potentially rival Apple's offering. However, significant improvements in user participation, notification systems, and overall functionality will be necessary for the network to reach its full potential.
For now, users of Find My Device compatible trackers may want to temper their expectations and keep a close eye on future updates to the service.