Google's latest flagship smartphone, the Pixel 9 Pro XL, has undergone thorough teardowns by repair experts, revealing a mix of positive and negative aspects when it comes to repairability. While the new dual-entry design offers easier access to internal components, some key issues persist, particularly with battery replacement.
Dual-Entry Design: A Step Forward
The Pixel 9 Pro XL introduces a dual-entry design, allowing repairs to be initiated from both the screen side and the back of the device. This approach marks a significant improvement over previous models and many competitors that only offer rear entry. The new design potentially simplifies screen repairs, a common issue for smartphone users.
Screen Repairs: Proceed with Caution
Despite the easier access, iFixit's teardown revealed a potential pitfall: the display layers are prone to separation during removal. This fragility means that even with improved access, screen repairs require extreme care to avoid irreparably damaging the panel.
Internal Component Access: Mixed Results
Accessing other internal components through the back of the device is now more straightforward. However, JerryRigEverything's teardown highlighted some challenges:
- Use of less common T4 screws around cameras and charging ports
- Hidden screws concealed under pieces of black tape
- Varying screw sizes complicating reassembly
- Numerous small brackets at risk of breaking during disassembly
The Battery Dilemma
Both iFixit and JerryRigEverything agree that battery replacement remains a significant hurdle. The battery is firmly glued to the device's body, and the pull tab mechanism provided for removal proves ineffective against the strong adhesive. Technicians must resort to using isopropyl alcohol and careful prying to extract the battery, a process that's both time-consuming and risky.
Repairability Score and Recommendations
iFixit provisionally scored the Pixel 9 Pro XL's repairability at 5/10, citing the difficult battery removal process and fragile display as major factors. JerryRigEverything's Zack was more critical, stating, From a repairability standpoint, I cannot recommend this phone to anyone.
Conclusion
While Google has made strides in improving access to the Pixel 9 Pro XL's internals, the device still presents significant challenges for repairs, especially concerning battery replacement. The new design shows promise, but there's clearly room for improvement in future iterations to make the Pixel series truly repair-friendly.
