The launch of Apple's new iMac with M4 chip has sparked intense discussion in the tech community, particularly around its memory limitations and design choices. While Apple touts significant performance improvements, the community's response reveals a complex mix of appreciation and criticism for this latest all-in-one desktop.
Key Specifications and Changes
- Base model starts at $1,299 with 16GB RAM (up from 8GB)
- Maximum RAM capacity of 32GB
- Available with 256GB to 2TB storage options
- 24-inch 4.5K Retina display
- New 12MP Center Stage camera
- USB-C ports (including peripherals)
- Available in multiple colors
The RAM Debate
One of the most contentious points is the 32GB RAM limitation. While this may be adequate for the target market - primarily home users, small businesses, and front-desk operations - professional users and developers have expressed frustration. The limitation seems particularly stark given that MacBook Pro models can support up to 128GB of RAM.
Apple's unified memory architecture offers significant performance benefits, but the non-upgradeable nature of the RAM, combined with Apple's traditionally high upgrade pricing, has drawn criticism from the community.
Target Market and Positioning
The iMac M4 appears clearly positioned for:
- Family computing
- Small business front desks
- Educational institutions
- Basic creative work
- General home office use
Many commenters note that the 24-inch form factor, while potentially limiting for power users, suits these target markets well. The all-in-one design, minimal cable management, and aesthetic appeal make it particularly attractive for shared spaces and customer-facing environments.
Performance Claims
Apple claims the M4 iMac is:
- 1.7x faster than M1 iMac for daily tasks
- 2.1x faster for demanding workflows
- Up to 4.5x faster than comparable Intel-based all-in-one PCs
However, some community members have questioned why Apple continues to use the M1 as a baseline for comparison rather than more recent M2 or M3 models.
Repairability and Sustainability Concerns
A significant portion of the discussion centers on repairability and longevity. Unlike previous generations of iMacs that could serve as external displays after their computing capabilities became outdated, newer models lack this functionality. This limitation has sparked debate about electronic waste and product longevity.
The Peripheral Update
In a welcome change, Apple has finally updated its accessories (Magic Keyboard, Mouse, and Trackpad) to USB-C charging ports, though the controversial bottom-charging design of the Magic Mouse remains unchanged.
Price-Performance Consideration
Starting at $1,299 with 16GB RAM and 256GB storage, the iMac M4 represents a significant investment. While the base RAM upgrade is welcome, the limited upgradeability and storage options mean buyers need to carefully consider their long-term needs at the time of purchase.
The community consensus suggests that while the iMac M4 excels at its intended use cases, power users and professionals might be better served by a Mac Studio or Mac mini paired with an external display, offering more flexibility and upgradeability options.