X (formerly Twitter) has implemented a controversial change to its blocking functionality, fundamentally altering how user privacy and content visibility work on the platform. This significant update has sparked widespread debate about user safety and privacy protection on social media.
The New Blocking Mechanism
The updated block feature now allows blocked users to view the blocker's public posts and profile, while still preventing direct interactions such as likes, reposts, or messages. This marks a substantial shift from the traditional blocking mechanism that completely restricted access to a user's content.
Privacy and Safety Implications
Critics have raised serious concerns about the update's impact on user safety. The change could potentially enable stalkers and abusive individuals to continue monitoring their targets, even after being blocked. While blocked users cannot directly interact, they can still screenshot and share content, potentially facilitating harassment through indirect means.
Platform Justification and Contradictions
X claims this change promotes transparency, stating it will help users identify when blocked individuals share harmful information about them. However, this reasoning appears to contradict the platform's earlier decision to hide post likes for privacy reasons. The inconsistency in privacy approach has led to questioning of the platform's true motives.
Competition and Alternative Options
Competing platforms have seized this opportunity to differentiate themselves. Bluesky, with its 13 million users, has explicitly stated it will maintain traditional blocking functionality. Meanwhile, Meta's Threads, boasting over 275 million users, continues to offer conventional blocking features. Users concerned about privacy can still set their X accounts to private, though this limits their overall platform visibility.
Regulatory and Store Policy Considerations
The update may potentially conflict with app store guidelines, particularly Apple's requirement for effective user blocking capabilities. However, X's apparently positive relationship with Apple, evidenced by the latter's continued advertising on the platform, might prevent immediate consequences.