Apple Intelligence vs. Google One AI Premium: Why Some AI Features Are Worth Paying For

BigGo Editorial Team
Apple Intelligence vs. Google One AI Premium: Why Some AI Features Are Worth Paying For

As smartphone manufacturers race to integrate artificial intelligence into their devices, users are left wondering which AI features actually enhance their daily experience and which are merely novelties. With Apple's recent rollout of Apple Intelligence and competitors like Google and Samsung advancing their own AI suites, the question emerges: are these features compelling enough to drive upgrades or justify subscription fees?

The Current State of Apple Intelligence

Apple Intelligence, despite its high-profile launch, has failed to become an essential tool for many iPhone users. Even tech enthusiasts who have access to Apple Intelligence-capable devices often find themselves forgetting about the features entirely. While certain functions like Mail's summary tool and Visual Intelligence have proven useful in specific situations, many other features like Image Playground and Memory Movies feel more like novelties than necessities.

The most anticipated component of Apple Intelligence—an upgraded Siri capable of working across multiple apps, understanding screen context, and engaging in natural conversations—has been significantly delayed. These advanced assistant capabilities, originally slated for iOS 18, may not appear until 2026 according to some reports. This delay represents both a setback for Apple's AI ambitions and a missed opportunity to deliver truly transformative AI experiences that users would actively seek out.

AI Features Across Competing Platforms

When comparing smartphone AI implementations, Google and Samsung currently offer more polished and practical tools than Apple. Google's Magic Editor sets the standard for AI-powered image editing, while its Recorder app's transcription and summarization capabilities deliver clear value. Samsung's Galaxy AI on the S25 series has introduced promising features like cross-app Gemini integration and the context-aware Now Brief feature that learns user preferences over time.

The fundamental challenge for all smartphone manufacturers is creating AI features that genuinely enhance the user experience rather than serving as flashy demonstrations of technical capability. Features that streamline common tasks, anticipate user needs, or solve real problems are far more valuable than those that merely generate content or perform tricks with limited practical application.

AI features demonstrated on a Google Pixel 9 Pro, highlighting Google's advancements in smartphone AI
AI features demonstrated on a Google Pixel 9 Pro, highlighting Google's advancements in smartphone AI

The Subscription Dilemma

As companies invest heavily in AI development, they're exploring ways to monetize these features. Nothing OS code suggests Essential Space may eventually cost USD 120 per year, while Samsung and Apple could potentially follow suit with subscription models for their AI features. However, convincing users to pay for features they're currently receiving for free presents a significant challenge.

Google One AI Premium, priced at USD 20 monthly, currently offers the most compelling value proposition among AI subscriptions. It combines mobile AI features with desktop capabilities, Gemini Advanced access, Google Workspace integration, and cloud storage benefits. The cross-device functionality creates a cohesive ecosystem that extends beyond smartphones to tablets, computers, and potentially cars and smart home devices in the future.

The Future of Mobile AI

For smartphone AI to truly succeed, it must evolve beyond isolated features to become an integral part of the user experience. Apple's delayed Siri improvements could eventually deliver this vision if they enable the assistant to genuinely understand context, anticipate needs, and work seamlessly across applications. Until then, most users will likely continue to view smartphone AI features as interesting but non-essential additions.

The companies that will win in the AI space are those that focus less on developing novel but impractical features and more on creating AI tools that solve real problems and integrate naturally into users' daily workflows. For subscription models to succeed, they'll need to offer value that extends beyond the smartphone itself, creating an ecosystem of AI assistance across all the devices users interact with throughout their day.

The integration of Google AI features in daily tasks, emphasizing the need for seamless functionality across devices
The integration of Google AI features in daily tasks, emphasizing the need for seamless functionality across devices
Review
…Total 30 reviews
👍 Strengths(57.6% of other opinions)
15.3%
Camera function and pixels
9%
Appearance and Design
7.4%
Battery Life
6.5%
Processor performance
4.2%
Additional features
👎 Weaknesses(63.4% of other opinions)
10.1%
Camera function and pixels
9%
Appearance and Design
7.7%
Price
5.5%
Battery Life
4.2%
Software support and updates