In a significant legal setback, tech giant Samsung has been ordered to pay $192 million for infringing on wireless charging patents owned by Mojo Mobility. This ruling, handed down by the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas, marks a pivotal moment in the ongoing battle over intellectual property in the mobile technology sector.
The case, which began in 2022, centers around five patents related to wireless charging technology. Mojo Mobility, a company specializing in wireless charging solutions, alleged that Samsung had been using their patented developments without authorization since 2016. The infringement reportedly spans across various Samsung products, including Galaxy smartphones, smartwatches, and earbuds.
Key points of the case include:
-
Failed Negotiations : In 2013, Mojo Mobility and Samsung engaged in licensing talks, with Mojo's representatives, including inventor Afshin Partovi, making several trips to Samsung's South Korean headquarters. However, these negotiations ultimately collapsed.
-
Intentional Infringement : Despite the failed licensing attempts, Samsung proceeded to implement the wireless charging technology across its product line without securing proper licensing agreements.
-
Legal Battle : The initial trial in January resulted in a $67.5 million judgment against Samsung, plus a $1.50 royalty per infringing device. However, confusion over running royalties versus lump-sum royalties led to a retrial.
-
Patent Validity Challenge : In 2023, Samsung attempted to invalidate the five patents in question but was largely unsuccessful. The Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) denied 15 of the 18 inter partes review (IPR) petitions filed by Samsung.
-
Potential Tripled Damages : Due to the finding of intentional infringement, the judge could potentially triple the damages, significantly increasing Samsung's financial liability.
This ruling puts Samsung in a precarious position. The company must now decide whether to pay the substantial fine or risk losing wireless charging capabilities in many of its popular devices. The decision also highlights the increasingly complex landscape of technology patents and the high stakes involved in their enforcement.
It's worth noting that this is not Samsung's only recent legal challenge in the Eastern District of Texas. In April, the company was hit with a $142 million judgment in a separate 5G patent infringement case.
As the tech industry continues to evolve rapidly, this case serves as a reminder of the importance of proper licensing and the potential consequences of patent infringement. It also underscores the ongoing tension between innovation and intellectual property rights in the highly competitive world of consumer electronics.
