The announcement of Gosub, a new browser engine written in Rust, has ignited a fascinating discussion within the developer community about the role of independent projects in challenging browser engine monopolies. While some question the necessity of building yet another browser engine, others defend the importance of diversity in this crucial technology space.
The Project and Its Goals
Gosub is developing a standalone browser engine that includes essential components such as an HTML5 tokenizer/parser, CSS3 parser, document tree, and rendering engine. The project, currently in its infancy, aims to provide an alternative to the Chrome/WebKit monopoly in the browser space.
Why Rust Matters
The choice of Rust as the programming language has drawn significant attention. Several developers in the community point out that Rust's memory safety features make it particularly well-suited for browser development, potentially eliminating up to two-thirds of security vulnerabilities commonly found in C/C++ implementations. This aligns with recent findings from Google's security team, which has reported substantial reductions in memory safety vulnerabilities through the use of Rust.
The Controversy
The project has sparked two main debates in the community:
-
Starting Fresh vs. Contributing to Existing Projects : Many developers question why the team didn't contribute to existing projects like Servo, which is also written in Rust. The project maintainers argue that starting fresh allows for greater control over the project's direction and implementation choices.
-
Feasibility Concerns : Some experienced developers, including former Mozilla employees, express concerns about the project's scope and complexity. Browser engine development requires extensive resources and compatibility with numerous web standards.
Current Status and Progress
The engine can currently:
- Parse HTML5 and CSS3 files into document trees
- Perform basic rendering of simple web pages
- Compile to WebAssembly for browser-based usage
However, the project acknowledges significant work remains, particularly in areas such as JavaScript integration and full web standard compliance.
Community Response
Despite skepticism, many developers support the initiative, drawing parallels to other successful open-source projects that started as just a hobby, such as Linux. The project has garnered 2.6k GitHub stars, indicating significant community interest, though it currently operates without financial sponsorship.
Looking Forward
While Gosub faces substantial challenges in becoming a fully-featured browser engine, its modular design and focus on memory safety through Rust position it as an interesting experiment in browser technology. Whether it succeeds as a full browser engine or finds its niche in specific use cases like web scraping or embedded systems remains to be seen.
The project serves as a reminder that even in spaces dominated by tech giants, there's still room for innovation and experimentation from independent developers.